How Does Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) Work for Psychiatry in New Jersey?

If you're using Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) in New Jersey to pay for psychiatric or therapy services, you’re in luck: BCBS is generally one of the most flexible insurers when it comes to mental health. But like all insurance plans, the key is knowing how your specific coverage works — especially if you're seeing a provider outside their network.

‍

Whether you’re seeking medication management, therapy, or both, understanding your out-of-network mental health benefits with BCBS can make the difference between peace of mind and surprise expenses. Check out their website specifically for seeing a mental health professional virtually or in-person in Monmouth county and New Jersey!

‍

How BCBS Handles Out-of-Network Psychiatry

BCBS offers strong reimbursement options for out-of-network providers, particularly under PPO and Federal Employee plans. If your psychiatrist or therapist doesn’t accept insurance directly, you can still see them and submit your receipts (superbills) for reimbursement.

This allows you to access specialized care — such as longer therapy sessions, concierge psychiatry, or integrated medication + therapy — while still getting partial reimbursement.

Understanding the Allowable Amount

BCBS reimburses based on an internal “allowable amount,” not the full fee charged. The percentage you receive back is based on your coinsurance rate (usually 60–80%) after you meet your deductible. Your deductable is the number that was given to you when you signed up (PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU KEEP IT IN MIND THROUGHOUT YOUR VISITS)

Example:

• If the allowable amount for a therapy session (90837) is $180 and your plan covers 70% post-deductible, you’d receive $126 back per session — even if your therapist charges $250.
  
  

‍

‍

Typical Allowable Amounts in NJ:

• 90837 (therapy, 60 minutes): $140–$200
  
  
• 90792 (psychiatric intake): $200–$300
  
  
• 99214 + 90833 (medication + therapy): $180–$280
  
  

What Determines Your Reimbursement:

• Your out-of-network deductible (often $500–$3,000)
  
  
• How much of that deductible you’ve already met
  
  
• Your coinsurance rate (what % you’re reimbursed after meeting deductible)
  
  
• Whether BCBS considers the treatment “medically necessary” (this is usually not a barrier)
  
  

How to Find Out What Your Plan Covers

Call the number on your BCBS card and ask:

• “Do I have out-of-network mental health benefits?”
  
  
• “What is my deductible, and how much have I met?”
  
  
• “What is my coinsurance rate for behavioral health?”
  
  
• “What are the allowable amounts for CPT codes 90792, 99214, and 90837?”
  
  
• “How do I submit a superbill or reimbursement claim?”
  
  

Knowing this information upfront will help you decide whether a specific provider is affordable — and help you plan your care accordingly.

How to Submit a Claim for Reimbursement

1. Request a superbill from your psychiatrist or therapist
   
   
2. Log into your BCBS portal or use their mobile app
   
   
3. Upload your claim and supporting documents
   
   
4. Monitor the claim and look out for reimbursement via check or direct deposit
   
   
5. Most BCBS reimbursements are processed within 30–60 days.
   ‍
   
   

Tips for Maximizing Your Benefits

• Consider combining sessions (e.g., monthly 60-minute sessions instead of biweekly 30-minute ones) if your provider offers flexible scheduling
  
  
• Always save copies of your Explanation of Benefits (EOBs)
  
  
• Use an out-of-network benefits tracker to tally costs and reimbursement amounts across the year
  
  
  

What If You're In-Network?

If you’re seeing an in-network BCBS provider, your visits are typically billed directly through insurance. You’ll pay a fixed copay (e.g., $25–$60) per session, and you won’t need to deal with superbills or reimbursement paperwork. The tradeoff is that these providers often have longer wait times and shorter sessions.

Final Thought

With the right information, BCBS can offer generous support for out-of-network psychiatric and therapy care in New Jersey. Whether you want the simplicity of in-network billing or the flexibility of a private provider, understanding your deductible, coinsurance, and allowable amounts puts you back in control. Mental health care should be accessible — and BCBS often makes it easier than you might think.

‍